Man gets 3 years in prison after restaurant meal thefts

2013-06-13T01:00:00Z 2013-06-13T11:16:43Z Man gets 3 years in prison after restaurant meal theftsBy DAVE FOPAY, JG-TC Staff Writer
June 13, 2013 1:00 am  • 

CHARLESTON — A prosecutor said a man offered no explanation for why he stole food from a restaurant by refusing to pay his bill for the second time in about two months.

The suspect, Anthony M. Malabehar, 47, whose address on record is 1721 DeWitt Ave., Mattoon, pleaded guilty to a theft charge that accused him of stealing from the Alamo Steak House restaurant in Mattoon on April 4. He was sentenced to prison for three years.

That incident took place less than a month after he pleaded guilty in a case that accused him of stealing from another Mattoon restaurant in the same fashion.

Police records in Malabehar’s case say he ordered a meal, an appetizer and drinks from the Alamo Steak House and then refused to pay the bill, which totaled nearly $70.

A theft of that amount is normally a misdemeanor offense but Malabehar was charged with a felony because of his criminal record, which apparently includes several theft and other property offense convictions in Cook County.

Malabehar was also eligible for an extended prison sentence, up to six years or twice the normal maximum, because of his earlier convictions. A burglary charge that accused him of entering the restaurant planning to steal was dismissed, and a conviction for that offense would have required a three- to 14-year prison term.

Also, Malabehar was discharged with an unsuccessful record from the supervision sentence he received for the earlier restaurant theft. In that case, he was accused of stealing food and drinks by refusing to pay his bill at Hunan Restaurant in Mattoon on Feb. 2.

Assistant State’s Attorney Rob Scales said Malabehar never gave an explanation of why he stole from the restaurants. During both incidents, he told restaurant workers that he couldn’t pay then waited for police to arrive without causing any other problems, Scales said.

Malabehar’s sentence also included restitution to the restaurant and a $100 fine. Circuit Judge Mitchell Shick based the sentence on a plea agreement that Scales and Public Defender Lonnie Lutz recommended.

Contact Fopay at or 217-238-6858.

Copyright 2015 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(5) Comments

  1. Hary P
    Report Abuse
    Hary P - June 18, 2013 8:29 pm
    And like some other moochers, he'll get his healthcare on the tax payers dime. Romney was right , darn those 47 percenters.
  2. Gordon MD
    Report Abuse
    Gordon MD - June 15, 2013 8:58 pm
    The Bible says "an eye for an eye" But USA Draconian law says a"a brain for a fingernail" thoroughly unjust.
  3. gnanny
    Report Abuse
    gnanny - June 13, 2013 12:41 pm
    Doesn't seem right 3 years for a couple of meals and probation for a couple of sexual abuse charges.
  4. Rosanna
    Report Abuse
    Rosanna - June 13, 2013 9:45 am
    Gringa, I agree, some form of community service and probation would have been more appropriate, but evidently they only give probation to men who sexually abuse 13 year old girls.
  5. gringa
    Report Abuse
    gringa - June 13, 2013 8:40 am
    Sounds like a mental health issue. (Yes, Har, that's PC talk for mental illness.)

    Now this guy gets a free hot and cot from the taxpayers for three years at a total cost of around $100,000.

    Instead of sending him to prison, I think Shick should have ordered the guy to do dishes at Hunan Restaurant and the Alamo for three years.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick


The JG-TC weekly roundup gives you the highlights of the week.

Get the latest offers and updates from local businesses in this weekly email.

Be among the first to know about special offers from businesses near where you live and work!

Get the latest local headlines from JG-TC. See an example

Don't miss a chance to win big! Get our periodic contest updates to stay in the know.

Receive the current days obituaries in your email!

Speak up


What is your favorite summertime activity?

View Results

Deals, Offers & Events

More Offers

Follow the JG-TC

Featured Businesses

More Businesses